Here is a trade from my own books. A PSA 10 Luffy stickered at $450 went out. Three raw cards and some cash came in, which is how a lot of trades at a show look, because the person across the table rarely has the full price in cash.
The three cards comped at $64.46 together. I credited them at 80%, which is $51.57, and the other $398.43 came in as cash. That is the whole trade, and every number in it was decided by two things, what each side is worth and what percentage the incoming cards are taken at.
How does a trade at a card show work?
Each side gets a value, and the difference is paid in cash. In my Luffy trade the slab went out at $450, the cards came in at $51.57, and $398.43 settled it.
The card going out is usually valued at the vendor's sticker, the same price you would pay in cash. The cards coming in are valued at what they sell for, then marked down to a trade percentage. Whoever's side comes up short pays the gap.
Sometimes nobody pays. Two cards of about the same value straight across is a trade too, it just happens that the cash on top is zero.
What percentage do vendors take trade cards at?
Higher than they pay in cash. Published shop rates for Pokemon singles run about 60% of market in cash and up to 80% in trade or store credit.
Those two figures come from Knight and Day Games' published rates, and the pattern holds across the trade. The Card Shop Finder puts the credit premium at 25 to 50 percent above whatever the cash offer was, so a $100 cash offer is commonly $125 to $150 in trade.
I take cards in at 80% on a trade, and the number moves with the card. Something everybody is chasing this month gets a better rate, and a card that is condition sensitive or falling after a release gets a worse one. A percentage is where a deal starts, not a rule.
Why do vendors give more in trade than in cash?
Because cash leaves the table and a traded card stays in the case. On my Luffy trade the 20% held back on the incoming cards was $12.89, and it only becomes money when those cards sell.
When I pay cash for a card, that money is gone today and I am betting I can sell the card for more later. When I take a card in trade, I am not spending anything. I am giving up a card I already priced, and the card coming in is inventory I expect to sell at its full value. That is why I can afford a better percentage on a trade, and it is why most vendors will.
It also means a trade is not finished when the customer walks away. The margin on those three cards is a number on paper until they sell.
Should you trade or sell to a vendor?
Trade if you want something on that table. On a $100 card, trade usually gets you $125 to $150 of value where cash gets you $100.
If you are walking out with a card you came for anyway, trading gets you more of it. If you need the money, or nothing on the table is what you want, cash is the honest choice, and the lower percentage is the price of the vendor taking on the risk of holding your card.
Asking for both numbers costs nothing, and a vendor who does trades will usually give you the cash offer and the trade offer side by side.
How do you keep track of a trade?
Write down both sides, not just the cash. My Luffy trade put $398.43 in the cash box, took a $450 slab out of the case and put three cards worth $64.46 into it.
This is the part most vendors skip, and it is why the books stop matching the case. The cash box only ever sees the $398.43. If that is all you record, the Luffy is still in your inventory on paper, the three new cards are not in it at all, and at the end of the weekend you cannot tell what you actually made.
The cards that came in also need a cost. They did not cost $64.46, which is what they sell for, and they did not cost nothing. They cost the $51.57 of credit you gave for them, and that is the number to measure their profit against when they sell.
VendBook records a trade as both sides at once. You scan what goes out and what comes in, set the trade percentage, and it works out the cash on top. The cash moves your balance, the outgoing card leaves your inventory, and the incoming cards land in it at the value you credited, all in the same step, so the books and the case never disagree.
Where these numbers come from
The Luffy trade is in my own ledger from September 2026, and it is the one shown in our short video on trade math. The incoming cards were comped from live market data at $64.46 and credited at 80%.
Shop rates are as published by the shops themselves and gathered in a Card Show 101 guide read on 12 November 2026. Pokemon singles at about 60% cash and up to 80% store credit are Knight and Day Games' rates, measured against market or TCGplayer low. The 25 to 50 percent credit premium is from The Card Shop Finder. These are shop rates rather than a survey of show vendors, and plenty of vendors run their own numbers.
← All articles