VendBook Download the app

How much less is a played Pokemon card worth?

Lightly Played
67.8%
of Near Mint, median of 1,332 cards
Moderately Played
43.4%
of Near Mint, median of 1,026 cards
LP cards under 85%
79%
of the 1,332, read 16 November 2026

The number most of us carry around for a Lightly Played card is 85% of Near Mint. It is easy to remember and it sounds about right. I pulled the live prices for every condition on 2,888 Pokemon cards to see whether it holds, and it does not. The market pays a lot less for played cards than the rule of thumb says.

How much less is a played Pokemon card worth?

At the median, a Lightly Played card sells for 67.8% of Near Mint, Moderately Played for 43.4%, Heavily Played for 27.5% and Damaged for 22.5%. Those are medians across every card in the sample that had at least three sales in that condition over the last 90 days.

What each condition sells for, against Near Mint Median across Pokemon cards with 3 or more sales in each condition over 90 days, read 16 November 2026
Near Mint
100%
Lightly Played
67.8%
Moderately Played
43.4%
Heavily Played
27.5%
Damaged
22.5%
Share of the Near Mint price

The steepest step is the first one. A card loses about a third of its value the moment it stops being Near Mint, and another quarter of the Near Mint price by Moderately Played. After that the drops get smaller, and Heavily Played and Damaged sit only five points apart.

Is Lightly Played really worth 85% of Near Mint?

For most cards, no. Of the 1,332 cards with enough Lightly Played sales to measure, 79% sold below 85% of their Near Mint price.

If you buy an LP card at 85% and price it to sell at 85%, you are paying more than the next buyer is likely to pay you. On a $20 card that gap is a few dollars. On a $200 card it is the margin on the whole deal.

What does that look like on a real card?

Here is Base Set Blastoise, a card that trades often in every condition. Near Mint was $230.22. Lightly Played was $138.25, which is 60%. Moderately Played was $85.81, Heavily Played $59.98 and Damaged $41.85.

So a Damaged Blastoise brings about 18% of a clean one. At an 85% LP rule you would have paid $195.69 for a copy the market values at $138.25.

Does every card drop that fast?

No, and this is the part that keeps condition pricing from being one percentage. The Crown Zenith Mew from the Galarian Gallery, GG10, sold Lightly Played for $56.45 against $63.96 Near Mint, which is 88%.

The spread between cards is wide, so a blanket percentage will be wrong in one direction or the other on most of them. It is a starting point when there is nothing better. When the card has its own condition prices, use those.

Does vintage drop faster than modern?

Less than I expected. For cards worth $20 or more Near Mint, Lightly Played came out at 66.1% for vintage Wizards of the Coast era sets and 65.8% for everything after. The big difference shows up further down the ladder. Heavily Played vintage held 34.1% of Near Mint against 23.8% for modern, so a beat up vintage card keeps noticeably more of its value than a beat up modern one.

Why do some played cards sell for more than Near Mint?

Because some markets are thin. In 108 of the 1,332 cards the Lightly Played price was above Near Mint, which almost always means a handful of sales moved one number and not the other. Nobody is paying a premium for whitening.

That is worth remembering at a table. If a played price looks too good, check how many sales are behind it before you trust it.

How do I price a played card at a show?

Look up the price for that card in that condition rather than taking a percentage off Near Mint. If the card has no condition prices of its own, use something closer to the medians above than to the 85% rule, and never let a worse condition come out higher than a better one.

VendBook shows a price for every condition from Near Mint to Damaged when you scan a card. It uses that card's own sold prices for each condition wherever they exist, fills in the rest from its own percentages, which you can set to your own numbers, and caps each step so a worse copy never prices above a better one.

Where these numbers come from

Every figure is from TCGplayer market prices for each condition, read through the JustTCG API on 16 November 2026. The sample was every English printing returned for 30 popular Pokemon names, 2,888 printings once duplicates were removed. A condition only counted when it had at least three sales in the last 90 days, and so did Near Mint, which is why the count differs for each condition. Vintage means the Wizards of the Coast sets from Base Set through Skyridge, plus the Wizards promos.

← All articles