Every table I set up, somebody hands me a card and asks whether they should grade it. The honest answer almost always comes down to the fee, and most people are working from a number that is either out of date or was never right.
So here are the real ones, read off both companies' own pricing pages, with the dates I read them. Then what 9,474 cards say about which company to send them to.
Is it worth grading a $40 card?
Usually not with PSA, and the reason is the fee. PSA's cheapest available service is $59.99 a card as of 8 October 2026, so a $40 card has to come back worth more than $100 before you have made a dollar. CGC will take the same card for $17 at Bulk, which moves the break even down to $57.
That gap is not small and it is not permanent. It exists because of one thing I will come back to below.
What does CGC actually charge?
Read off cgccomics.com on 5 October 2026:
| Tier | Price | Max declared value | Turnaround |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bulk | $17 | $500 | 150 business days |
| Economy | $20 | $1,000 | 90 business days |
| Standard | $55 | $3,000 | 10 business days |
| Express | $100 | $10,000 | 5 business days |
| WalkThrough | $300 | no cap | 2 business days |
Bulk needs 25 cards in the submission. If you have got nine cards worth doing, you are on Economy at $20 and the maths changes.
What does PSA actually charge?
Read off psacard.com on 8 October 2026:
| Tier | Price | Max declared value | Turnaround |
|---|---|---|---|
| Value | $24.99 | $500 | 120 business days |
| Standard | $59.99 | $1,000 | 90 to 100 business days |
| Priority | $79.99 | $1,500 | 70 to 80 business days |
| Express | $199 | $2,500 | 20 to 30 business days |
| Super Express | $349 | $5,000 | 10 to 15 business days |
| Premier | $599 | $10,000 | 7 to 10 business days |
Value is paused. That is the single most important line in this article. PSA's $24.99 tier is not accepting submissions, so their cheapest real option is Standard at $59.99. Every piece of advice you read that says PSA costs about $25 a card was written while Value was open, and it is wrong today.
When Value comes back, most of what follows flips.
The tier is set by what the card is worth now, not after it grades
This catches people out and it costs real money. Declared value is what the card is worth as you send it, raw. A $141 card is a $141 card, so it declares into the cheapest tier that covers it.
It is tempting to declare what you think a 10 will be worth. Do not. I priced a Ninetales that way once and put it in CGC Express at $100 when the honest answer was Bulk at $17, which turned a real 29.3x return into 19.4x on paper and nearly talked me out of a good card.
So when does CGC beat PSA?
On cheap cards, and the crossover is sharper than I expected. These are 9,474 Pokemon cards priced on 8 October 2026, each one costed both ways using the fee tier its own raw price puts it in, then compared against what a 10 actually sells for in each company's holder.
| Raw price of the card | CGC wins | PSA wins |
|---|---|---|
| Under $20 | 56.6% | 43.4% |
| $20 to $50 | 36.3% | 63.7% |
| $50 to $100 | 5.1% | 94.9% |
| $100 to $250 | 3.7% | 96.3% |
| Over $250 | 1.7% | 98.3% |
Under $20, CGC takes it more often than not. Somewhere between $20 and $50 it flips. Past $50 it is not really a decision any more, PSA wins about 19 times out of 20.
Across all 9,474 cards it comes out PSA 61.4% and CGC 38.6%.
Why does PSA win almost everything over $50?
Because a PSA 10 sells for more than a CGC 10 of the same card, and once the card is expensive enough, that premium is worth more than the $43 you saved on the fee.
On a $15 card the fee is most of your cost, so saving $43 is the whole game. On a $300 card the fee is noise and the only thing that matters is what the slab sells for. The crossover is just the point where those two swap over, and right now it lands in the $20s and $30s.
What should I do with a box of commons?
Mostly nothing. The thing nobody tells you is that the great majority of cards are not worth grading by either company at any price, and the ones that are tend not to be the ones people bring to the table.
If you are going to do it, the shape that works is to hold cheap candidates back until you have 25 of them and send that as one CGC Bulk submission at $17 a card, and send anything over about $50 raw to PSA individually. Mixing those up is how a submission ends up costing more than it returns.
Where these numbers come from
The fee tables above are read off CGC's and PSA's own pages and stored with the date they were read, so a return computed for a given day uses the fee that applied on that day. We never write down a fee we have not read that week, because a guessed fee produces a confident wrong answer, which is worse than saying nothing.
The card figures come from real near mint prices and real sold prices for graded copies, refreshed daily. You can see the current list of cards where the spread is actually worth acting on at vendbook.app/research.
One honest caveat on all of it. None of this says a card will grade a 10. It is what the spread looks like if it does, with the fee already taken out. Centering, edges and surface decide the rest, and they are your problem.
← All articles