VendBook Download the app

What happens if your card comes back a 9?

PSA 10 against PSA 9
4.59x
median across 9,421 cards
Clear the fee at a 10
88.5%
priced 14 October 2026
Still clear it at a 9
72.9%
the gap is the whole bet

Everybody does the grading math on a 10. They look up what the PSA 10 sells for, subtract the fee, and decide it is worth sending. Almost nobody prices the other outcome, which is the one that happens far more often.

So I ran it. Here is what a 9 is actually worth against a 10 across 9,421 Pokemon cards, which ones stop making money the moment you miss the 10, and what that looks like on a card you have probably held.

What is a PSA 9 actually worth compared to a 10?

The median PSA 10 sells for 4.59 times the same card in a PSA 9. Half of all cards land between 2.7 times and 8.16 times.

That number surprises people who have only ever compared a 9 to a raw copy. One grade is not a ten or twenty percent haircut. On a typical card it is most of the value, and on the top quarter of cards the 10 is worth more than eight of the 9.

It is worth saying plainly that this is a price ratio, not a prediction. It tells you what each outcome pays. It does not tell you which one you are going to get.

Will a 9 still cover the grading fee?

Usually, but a lot less often than a 10 does. Of the 9,421 cards, 88.5% are worth more as a PSA 10 than the card plus the fee cost to get there. At a 9 that falls to 72.9%.

The 15.6 points in between are the cards that only work if you hit the 10. On those, a 9 is not a smaller win. It is a loss.

Which cards lose money at a 9?

The cheap ones, and it is not close. The lower the raw card's value, the more of your return is sitting on the 10.

How often the grading fee is covered, by what the raw card is worth 9,421 cards priced 14 October 2026, against PSA fees read 15 October 2026
Under $25
81.2%
$25 to $100
98%
$100 to $500
99.3%
$500 and up
100%
Covered even at a PSA 9Only covered if it grades a 10

Under $25 raw, a third of cards lose money at a 9. Above $500, almost nine in ten still clear the fee, and every single one of them clears it at a 10.

This is the opposite of how most people submit. The instinct is to send the cheap stuff because the downside feels small. The cheap stuff is exactly where the downside is largest as a share of what you put in, because a $59.99 fee on a $24 card is most of your cost no matter what grade comes back.

Can a PSA 9 be worth less than the raw card?

Yes, on about 1 card in 25. It happened on 375 of the 9,421, or 4.0%.

That is the outcome worth bracing for. You paid the fee, waited the turnaround, and the slab is worth less than what you put in the envelope. It is not common, but it is common enough that you will see it if you submit regularly.

What does this look like on a real card?

Take the Mega Dragonite ex #271 from Ascended Heroes, which is one of the most heavily traded cards in the set right now.

The raw card is $24.04. PSA's cheapest available tier is $59.99, so you have $84.03 in it before anything is graded.

Mega Dragonite ex #271, what each outcome pays raw and graded prices 14 October 2026, PSA Standard fee read 15 October 2026
What you have in it
$84.03
Comes back a 9
$39.28
Comes back a 10
$113.87
The raw card, $24.04PSA Standard fee, $59.99What the slab sells for

The 10 makes you $29.84. The 9 loses you $44.75. You are risking more than you stand to make, on a card whose 10 is only worth 2.9 times its 9, which is below the median.

It gets starker on expensive cards. The Pikachu with Grey Felt Hat promo is $1,009.41 raw and goes in at the $79.99 Priority tier, so $1,089.40 all in. A 10 sells for $2,453.38. A 9 sells for $867.19, which is $222.21 less than you put in and less than the raw card was worth before you sent it.

So should I still grade it?

Three things follow from the numbers, and none of them is "don't grade."

Grade the cards where a 9 is still fine. Those are the ones where you keep your money back even on the common outcome, and above $100 raw that is more than four cards in five.

Be much more careful under $25. That band is where two thirds clear at a 9 and a third do not, and it is the band most people submit the most of.

Look at the 10 to 9 ratio on the specific card, not the average. A card whose 10 is worth 8 times its 9 is a completely different bet from one at 2.9 times, even if both look profitable on a spreadsheet that only prices the 10.

What are the odds of actually getting a 10?

I do not know, and I would not trust anyone who gives you one number for it.

This is the honest limit of everything above. These figures price the outcomes. They say what a 9 pays and what a 10 pays. They say nothing about how likely each one is, because that depends on the card's centering and surface, on the set and how it was printed, and on how well you pick and pack. A modern card pulled from a pack and sleeved straight away is a different proposition from the same card out of a binder.

What the data does let you do is stop pricing one outcome and calling it a plan. If you only make money on the 10, you should at least know that is the bet you are making.

Where these numbers come from

Prices are the 14 October 2026 snapshot of our card price archive, covering 9,421 Pokemon cards that carry both a PSA 9 and a PSA 10 price. Cards without both are excluded, which is why that count is lower than the 9,474 used in the grading cost post.

Grading fees were read off PSA's own pricing page on 15 October 2026. Standard is $59.99 a card up to $1,000 declared value, Priority is $79.99 up to $1,500, and Value Services are still paused, which is why $59.99 is the cheapest PSA option rather than the number you may remember. CGC's fees were read the same day, where Bulk is $17 a card up to $500 with a 25 card minimum. The tier used for each card is set by what the raw card is worth when you send it, not by what it might be worth after it grades.

Every figure here is computed against those fees on that date. When a company changes its pricing, the multiples move, which is the entire reason we read the pages rather than quoting numbers from memory.

← All articles