Here is one Wednesday from my own books. I sold four cards for $795.00 and bought five for $293.00. The cash went up $502.00, and if you had asked me that night how the day went I would have said five hundred bucks.
I made $194.52. The other $307.48 was not profit at all, and the reason why is the whole problem with running a table off a cash count.
How do you track profit at a card show?
Profit is what a card sold for minus what that card cost you, added up over everything that sold. On my Wednesday that was $795.00 in sales against $600.48 of cost, so $194.52.
That is the only number that tells you whether the day made money. It needs two figures for every card that leaves your case, the price it went for and the price you paid for it, and the second one is the one most vendors do not have written down anywhere.
Why doesn't the cash box show your profit?
Because it mixes three different things into one number. Money from sales, money spent on new inventory, and the cost of the cards you just sold, which left your case without ever touching the box.
On my Wednesday it works out exactly:
- $194.52 of profit on the four cards that sold.
- $600.48 back, which is what those four cards had cost me. Selling them turned that much inventory back into cash. It is my own money returning, not money I made.
- $293.00 out, spent on five new cards. That money is not gone, it is sitting in the case as inventory.
$194.52 plus $600.48 minus $293.00 is the $502.00 in the box. Every dollar is accounted for, and only a third of it is profit.
What does a buying day look like?
Like a loss, when it is not one. On November 2nd I made five buys for $2,850.74 and sold nothing, so the box went down by almost three thousand dollars.
I did not lose a cent that day. I swapped cash for cards, and the cards are in my case at what I paid. Whether that day was a good one gets decided later, when those cards sell, and what they sell for against the $2,850.74 is the profit.
This is the day that scares newer vendors, because a heavy buying weekend can leave you with less cash than you walked in with and a case that is worth more than it was on Friday. Read only the box and you will think you had a bad show.
How do you count a trade?
Write down both sides. The cash on top goes in the box, but the card going out and the cards coming in change your case, and the box never sees either one.
I wrote a whole post on how trades work at a card show, and the short version for your books is this. The cards that come in cost you whatever credit you gave for them, not their market price and not zero. Record that number, because it is what you measure their profit against when they sell.
What do you need to write down for every deal?
The cards, what you paid or what you sold them for, and the date. For a sale, also the cost of each card that went out, which is the number that turns a sale into a profit.
That is the hard part to keep up by hand. At a table you are doing a deal every few minutes, and nobody wants to look up what they paid for a card three months ago while the next person is waiting. So the cost basis does not get written down, and at the end of the weekend there is a cash total and a guess.
A spreadsheet works if you fill it in that night. The trouble is that by that night you are reconstructing it from memory, and a trade or a bundle sale is exactly what memory gets wrong.
How do you know what your inventory is worth?
Count it two ways, at what you paid and at what it sells for today. My case right now is 61 cards, $4,554.10 at cost and $6,032.54 at market.
The gap between those, $1,478.44, is profit that does not exist yet. It is real in the sense that those cards would sell for that, and not real in the sense that they have not. Keeping it separate from the profit you have actually banked is what stops a good looking case from hiding a slow month.
Is there an app that tracks this for you?
VendBook records every buy, sale and trade with the cards attached, so the cost of each card is already there when it sells. The profit on a sale is worked out the moment you log it, cards you buy go into your inventory at what you paid, and a trade moves your cash by the money on top while both sides of the cards land in the right place.
At the end of a day it shows what you took in, what you spent, what sold for how much more than it cost, and what is still in the case at cost and at market. That is the five hundred bucks question answered properly, and it takes no counting.
Where these numbers come from
Every figure is from my own VendBook ledger. The Wednesday is 23 September 2026: Sabrina's Gengar sold for $550.00 against a cost of $419.99, a 1st Edition Haunter for $95.00 against $68.74, Meowth ex for $80.00 against $59.50, and Sabrina's Alakazam for $70.00 against $52.25. The two buys that day came to $185.00 and $108.00. I also did a trade that day, which is left out here because the card I traded away has no cost recorded, and a profit figure built on a guess is the thing this post is arguing against.
The buying day is 2 November 2026, five buys totalling $2,850.74. The inventory figures are my case as of 9 November 2026.
← All articles